Category: Accessibility

Know Before You Go: Finding Accessible Cultural Attractions in Boston

Vintage old time movie theatre with marqueeSightseeing and leisure travel present unique challenges to individuals with disabilities, their families, friends, and companions. No one wants to make a special effort to go somewhere only to find out that you can’t get in; or there are no restrooms that meet your needs; or you can’t find out if the food is safe for you to eat; or that you can’t hear the performance or guided tour.

This demand for accessible cultural attractions is increasing and many places are responding in very positive and creative ways. But how do you find out what accessibility features are available at the place you are visiting?

The internet as an accessibility resource

The internet is a good place to start, yet while some destinations provide a lot of information, others do not. Some places put access information on the front page of their website; others bury it four layers down. There is no “best practice” as to what, how or where access information is provided.

In planning family outings myself, I noticed and was troubled by this lack of consistent information. That is why I started www.exploreboston.org.

Website presents accessible attractions in the Boston area

In 2010, I was awarded the Barbara Wilensky Gopen Memorial Fellowship by the Massachusetts Developmental Disabilities Network in order to create a website that provides comprehensive and comprehensible access information for many of the most popular attractions in Boston.

My goal was to provide information that made it useful to, and usable by, as many people as possible.

By only targeting accessibility information to people with disabilities, this important information was not getting to everyone who could benefit from it; yet the fact remains that varying levels of ability are a normal part of human life. It also perpetuates an “us” and “them” mentality where people with disabilities are treated as different from all other visitors.

Accessibility at cultural attractions benefits everyone

Access is for everyone. Ramps and elevators are vital for people who use wheelchairs, but they are also vital for parents with strollers. Captioning on videos is important to people who are deaf and hard of hearing, but it also benefits children learning to read and people learning English as a second language.

During my fellowship project, I learned about a number of wonderful resources on accessible cultural attractions and I am looking forward to sharing these resources with you over

Nora Nagle
Guest author Nora Nagle

the next month!

Resources for Making Websites Useable by People with Cognitive Disabilities

One does not have to be a web developer to help make a site usable by people with cognitive disabilities. Creating clear, simple website content is equally important.

What Are Cognitive Disabilities?

Cognitive disabilities are experienced by people, for example, who have dyslexia, or attention deficit disorder (ADD), or depression, and by all of us as we age. Cognitive disabilities are functionally characterized, in large part, by poor comprehension, attention and memory.

Within the United States, there are no widely-used and accepted definitions of cognitive disability. However, WebAIM has a functional definition of cognitive disabilities, which is good for web developers.

How Can a Website Be Made Usable by People with Cognitive Disabilities?

Using plain language throughout a site is a great start. There are five good design features and five good content features that would definitely make a website easier to use by people with cognitive disabilities. WebAIM has an informative article about evaluating cognitive web accessibility.

How Can a Website Be Determined Good for People with Cognitive Disabilities?

A terrific resource is WebAIM’s cognitive accessibility checklist, which is very useful for web developers.

I have been evaluating the cognitive accessibility of websites by organizations that serve people with cognitive disabilities. To date, I have found two of twenty sites to be accessible. For information about the methodology and the results of this work, see Cognitive Web Accessibility: Assessments.

There has also been research in this area. For a recent example, see Improving Web Searching for People with Cognitive Disabilities.

The best way to determine if a website is good for people with cognitive disabilities is to have them test it!

Additional Resources

Previous, Related Blog Posts

Note: Information about me and my work.

Making Websites Usable by People with Cognitive Disabilities

It does not have to be difficult to make websites usable by people with cognitive disabilities. They benefit by the same design features employed for people with physical disabilities. The main difference is they also need website content that is accessible to them.

Some Good Design Features

  • consistent page layout with headings and liberal white space;
  • minimal distractions, such as advertisements or unrelated content;
  • large text (font) size, with minimal use of italics;
  • straightforward, consistent site navigation; and
  • site search that corrects spelling, offers relevant synonyms, and presents simple results.

Some Good Content Features

  • succinct, plain language that is literal (e.g., no colloquialisms, sarcasm or jargon);
  • page sections defined visibly, with textual content written in chunks;
  • simple summaries for complex- or lengthy content;
  • pairing of textual content with contextually-relevant images, icons and graphics; and
  • presentation of textual content via video and/or text-to-speech alternatives.

Example Websites

To date, I have found two websites that have made significant efforts to be usable by people with cognitive disabilities, particularly intellectual disabilities.

People First

The People First site features a large site-navigation menu (the following image). For menu options, there are contextually-relevant icons, which are also used throughout the site.
People First Site Navigation MenuThe Mencap site incorporates many captioned videos (example image following) as an alternative to textual content, and relevant images to augment it. The site’s My Life section is specifically designed for constituents, with plain language; simple navigation; and lots of images and videos.
Man pictured with a quote: We work in partnership with the parents.

Examples of Web Use by People with Cognitive Disabilities

People with cognitive disabilities use the web for the same reasons we all do, primarily: to communicate; to consume content; and to purchase goods and services. Where they differ is in how able they are to engage in these endeavors, and to overcome the barriers presented by websites not designed with simplicity in mind.

How easy is it to find and buy something?

Shopping sites are good examples of complexity. Retailers apparently believe that to attract customers their websites must have animated promotions, display large numbers of products, and employ sophisticated site-navigation systems. These same features overwhelm people with cognitive disabilities.

The following video is of Martin visiting the Amazon.com website. Note the one action common sense would say Amazon would want to make the easiest, that of purchasing an item, is quite difficult for him to accomplish. He makes good points about why that is.

How easy is it to find information?

Other than shopping, common interests among people with intellectual disabilities I have interviewed include:

  • using social media sites and web-based email; and
  • finding information related to local movie schedules, food recipes, self advocacy and disabilities.

Related to the latter interest, I interviewed Mary about her use of the DisabilityInfo.org website, the home to this blog.

Mary told me the home page, represented by the following image, was too full of choices.  I designed it, and I agree with her. It is cluttered with many links and images.

web page with over 50 links, over 25 images, and 3 columns of information

Trying to use the site’s search box proved equally overwhelming for Mary. Like most people, she did not know what human service terms to use to find relevant information. Tangentially-relevant search terms and spelling errors also thwarted her efforts to find the information she needed. Once Mary found some search results, trying to understand their content and determining their relevancy was troublesome.

Conclusion

Finding and understanding information is very difficult for people with cognitive disabilities. It is just as important for DisabilityInfo.org to facilitate those tasks as it is for Amazon.com to enable its users to buy products. The next blog post will focus on how to make websites more usable by people with cognitive disabilities.

Notes

Making Web Sites Usable By Everyone

Billions of websites offer great information and services. Yet the vast majority are not designed to be usable by everyone, especially people with disabilities. Those websites that are designed to be accessible are reasonably focused on people with physical disabilities. Almost none of those, unfortunately, are designed for people with cognitive disabilities.

Problems with comprehension, memory, attention, or problem solving, which are experienced by people with cognitive disabilities, are just as important for web designers to circumvent as those experienced by people with physical disabilities. There are two significant reasons that web designers should make their sites usable by everyone.

  1. There are millions of people who have disabilities. All of us will acquire disabilities as we age. Thinking quickly and easily will become more difficult. Our vision and hearing will likely deteriorate as well.
  2. Excluding millions of people from using websites, or making it difficult for them to do so, is bad for business. It does not matter if a website’s purpose is to make money or to provide a public service. Excluding people equals mission failure.

Working To Solve The Problems

Organizations and activists around the world are helping web designers make their sites usable by everyone. There are a few, such as I, who are exploring how to make websites usable by people with cognitive disabilities. I have spent my entire professional career serving that population, particularly those with intellectual disabilities and/or autism. Since the web was born, I have been developing web sites as usable by people with disabilities as technology and funding has allowed.

Clear Helper LogoA couple of years ago, I decided to combine those two passions in earnest. I have been working to explore and to develop best practices of web usability/accessibility for people with cognitive disabilities. One of my goals is to develop a website to teach web skills to people with intellectual disabilities, and that itself is accessible to them. For more information, see my Clear Helper Blog.

Related Future Blog Posts

This post is the first in a four-part series. Upcoming topics will be:

  • using web sites from the perspective of people with cognitive disabilities;
  • what can be done by web designers to make their sites more accessible for people with cognitive disabilities; and
  • resources that will help everyone interested in cognitive web accessibility.

Background Information

Accessible Recreation Provides Exciting Options This Summer

Group of people in kayaks

Take advantage of the many wonderful outdoor accessible activities in Massachusetts this summer. The links below provide information on a number of possibilities-check them out to find a good fit for you.

Please note most programs require preregistration.

All Out Adventures, Easthampton provides outdoor accessible recreational opportunities throughout Massachusetts for people of all abilities, their families and friends. Summer programs include accessible kayaking, canoeing, hiking and cycling. (413) 527-8980, info@alloutadventures.org

Free Accessible Swimming Pools, including lifts, are available at all of the MA State Parks and Recreation Department’s 20 swimming pools.

AccesSport America, Acton offers high-challenge sports for children & adults with disabilities. Programs including kayaking, windsurfing and water skiing.
Ross Lilley, Executive Director, info@accessportamerica.org ,
(978) 264-0985

Barrier Free Massachusetts Playgrounds, offers inclusive playgrounds where children and adults of all abilities can play in a fun environment.

CHD Disability Resources – Adaptive Sports Program , Springfield includes a variety of adaptive sports providing barrier-free recreational and competitive opportunities for people of all skill levels and age groups.
Nancy Bazanchuk, Director, nbazanchuk@chd.org, (413) 788-9695

Community Boating, Inc. Universal Access Sailing Program, Charles River in Boston offers persons with disabilities and their guests use of accessible sailboats, transfer equipment, staff assistance for transferring and sailing instruction all for only $1.00.
Marcin Kunicki, UAP Director, (617) 523-1038 x24
marcin@community-boating.org

Community Rowing, Inc., Charles River in Boston offers beginning and experienced rowers trained staff and adaptive equipment. Call in advance for fees, scheduling, and needs assessment.
Chris Obusek, (617) 779-8267.
Check out CRI Adaptive Rowing Video

Mass DCR Universal Access Program provides outdoor recreation opportunities in Massachusetts State Parks for visitors of all abilities. Accessibility to Massachusetts State Parks is achieved through site improvements, specialized adaptive recreation equipment, and accessible recreation programs. Gigi Ranno, (617) 626-1294 (Eastern Mass) or
Marcy Marchello, (413) 545-5758 (Western Mass).
Download Universal Accessible Brochure .

Outdoor Explorations, Medford provides one-day clinics and multi-day overnight trips with activities including kayaking, backpacking, sailing, rock climbing and whitewater rafting. (781) 395-4999, info@outdoorexp.org

Piers Park Sailing , Boston Harbor provides programs for disabled youth and adults aboard 23-foot sonar sailboats. Adaptive sailing program is led by 2008 Paralympic Gold Medalist Maureen McKinnon-Tucker.
(617) 561-6677, maureen@piersparksailing.org

Recreation Opportunities MNIP Fact Sheet lists additional recreational opportunities in Massachusetts.

Have a great summer!

Sailing For All on the Charles

wheel chair on accessible boating dock

Enjoy sailing? This week we introduce a wonderful program offering accessible sailing in Boston.

Sailing as an option this summer

Community Boating Inc. (CBI) Universal Access Program offers persons with disabilities and their guests the joy of sailing lessons or recreational sailing on the scenic Charles River. CBI provides specialized modified sailboats, adaptive support, staff assistance for transferring in and out of sailboats and sailing instruction for only $1 per person. Staff are trained to offer assistance to all people with disabilities including those with physical and intellectual challenges as well as people on the spectrum.

Reserved sessions average an hour in length and can be customized to meet individual needs. They can include sailing lessons or a short sailboat ride for therapeutic recreation.

Marcin Kunicki, Universal Access Program Director, has fourteen dedicated staff and four adaptive sailboats. Seat configurations in the boats are available for people with different needs.  The Sonar, 23’ is the largest sailboat which seats six participants.

Dock restoration and growing program

The dock has been recently restored through the Community Boating Restoration Project funded by generous donations from the Commonwealth, DCR, The Solomon Fund, Esplanade Association, Mugar Foundation and Community Boating. The restoration project will increase Community Boating’s program schedule by offering accessible sailing every day this coming summer.

Marcin reports there were over 700 reservations booked last year for the Adaptive Sailing Program. With the upgrades to the dock and its growing program, he recommends those interested make reservations early this summer.

Empowering experience

Marcin describes the experience as more than just a recreational activity.
“It is a liberating and empowering experience for everyone involved. Many have expressed that because they have tried Community Boating, it has given them confidence to do other things.”

Contact Marcin Kunicki to reserve your sailing session at (617) 523-1038.

Recreate Yourself through Recreation

Several individuals hiking some with wheel chairs

This week I am pleased to introduce guest blogger, Marcy Marchello, an Accessible Recreation Coordinator for the Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation’s Universal Access Program. This wonderful program serves people with disabilities and their families, friends and caregivers interested in accessing our state parks.Marcy Marchello sitting by a stream

Marcy finds her role

“How did I end up in such a unique role? Though I do not have a disability, I was introduced to many people with disabilities in my youth and worked as a personal care assistant as an adult. I spent quite a few hours accompanying my father while he visited a institutions and therapeutic settings to design various products, such a custom wheelchair seating, helmets, and swimming aids.

As an avid outdoors person, I have explored many pursuits from birding to skiing, and experienced the personal benefits of exercise, play, nature observation, teamwork, and outdoor exploration. When an opportunity arose to combine these experiences to improve outdoor accessibility for those with disabilities, I went for it!”

Blog offers excellent resources

Everyone Outdoors is a blog I designed to be a “go-to” resource for people with disabilities, their friends and family. It was written in conjunction with a grant project, REC Connect, seeking to assist people with disabilities in their exploration of recreation and skills progression.

Here you’ll find accessible places to visit and things to do, from a quiet nature walk to adventurous excursions such as sailing in Boston Harbor or hiking in a state park. Personal stories, program opportunities, equipment reviews and more are featured, covering a wide range of disability and recreation experiences.

I hope you’ll visit Everyone Outdoors and find useful information and new opportunities within its pages. Enjoy the blog at https://www.everyoneoutdoors.blogspot.com/.

Feedback and comments are welcome. In addition, if you’d like to submit a blog post about your own experience, feel free to contact me at marcy.marchello@state.ma.us.”

Enjoying the Accessible Outdoors

Six kayaks lined up with happy people inside

After a tough winter many of us are beginning to plan our summer vacations and outdoor activities. This month we present an overview of accessible activities in Massachusetts for people of all ages and abilities to enjoy throughout the summer.

Website presents accessible summer optionswoman in beach wheel chair looking into the sun

The Mass Department of Conservation & Recreation Universal Access Program UAP provides accessible recreational opportunities in Massachusetts’ state parks, including accessible beaches, trails and fishing locations. UAP inclusive programs include adaptive boating (kayaking, canoeing, sailing & rowing), cycling and more. Most programs require pre-registration; paddling and hiking programs include fees. All program participants must complete a liability waiver.

Come to the Accessible Recreation Fair

DCR’s annual free Accessible Recreation Fair is Saturday, June 4 at Artesani Park, 1234 Soldiers Field Road in Brighton (Boston) from 10:00AM – 3:00PM. This is a great place to learn about summer recreation programs, meet representatives from recreational organizations in the Boston area, and to try out cycles and all-terrain wheelchairs. Refreshments provided.
Call Gigi Ranno to register at (617) 626-1294.

The month ahead

In the weeks to come, you will be introduced to Marcy Marchello, an accessible recreation coordinator for the Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation’s Universal Access Program. Marcy is a passionate outdoor enthusiast with an impressive blog, “Everyone Outdoors”. You will want to subscribe to Marcy’s blog to keep informed of all the exciting opportunities Massachusetts has to offer.

You will also learn about an accessible and very affordable sailing program on the Charles River through Marcin Kunicki, Director of the Community Boating Universal Access Sailing Program.

In our final blog of the month you will have links to a variety of accessible outdoor activities in Massachusetts including contact information to get you started on making your plans.

With all this information, we hope you get excited and make this summer a special one….be adventurous and try something new.